When choosing a dog, there are many things to consider – size, energy level, coat type, and more. But one of the most critical factors in choosing a breed that fits your lifestyle.
We’ll cover two popular breeds – the XL American Bully and the German Shepherd – large dogs with vastly different personalities.
Are you torn between choosing an XL Bully or a German Sheperd?
Before making any decisions, it’s essential to do your research. We’ve created this comprehensive guide comparing the Xl American bully dog vs. the German shepherd. We want to ensure you have all the information you need to make the best decision for your needs and lifestyle.
These dogs are famous for families but have different personalities and needs. We want to help you find the perfect dog for your home – whether a playful pup who loves to run and play or a cuddly companion who will be by your side through thick and thin.
A Quick History
Before our Xl Bully vs. German Shepherd Comparison, let’s look at the two breeds.
The XL Bully is a hybrid of the American Bully and the XL Pitbull. They are large dogs with bloodlines from some popular bully breeds, such as the American Staffordshire Terrier or American Pit Bull Terrier, the English Bulldog, and the French Bulldog.
The German Shepherd, also known as Alsatian Wolf Dog, on the other hand, is a purebred dog that was developed in Germany in the late 19th century. They were originally bred as herding dogs, but they quickly became famous for their loyalty, obedience, and working ability.
Comparison
These two dog breeds are undoubtedly excellent choices. Now, let’s take a look at some key differences you should consider before making your final decision.
Size
Choosing the right size dog is one of the essential factors in selecting a breed. It will determine the amount of space you need, how much food they will eat, and even how much exercise they will need.
Larger dogs may require more space but tend to be more relaxed and laid-back. Smaller dogs, on the other hand, maybe less work in terms of exercise and food, but they require more attention and may not be suitable for families with small children.
The XL Bully is a large dog weighing around 100-120 pounds. The German Shepherd, on the other hand, is a medium to large breed, weighing about 50-90 pounds.
Variety
American Bully comes in four sizes: pocket bully, standard, XL, and XXL. The German Shepherd, on the other hand, has three different types – American show lines, West German show lines, and East German working lines.
Another factor that may affect your decision is the variety of colors and sizes each breed has. Check out the different shades of each species below.
XL Bully:
- Blue
- Black
- Red
- White
German Shepherd:
- Black
- Tan
- Red
- White
Color may not seem important, but it can help you choose a dog that fits your personality and style.
Food and Diet
Your choice of companion dog may also affect your food budget. Larger dogs like the XL Bully will eat more food than smaller breeds. They may also require a different type of food, such as a high-protein diet, to maintain their energy levels.
The German Shepherd is a medium to large breed, so they will also eat more than smaller breeds. However, their diet is not as specialized as the XL Bully, and they can usually get by on a standard dog food diet.
Top Food Selection for XL Bullies
Most bullies are food-motivated, so choosing the right food is essential to keep them happy and healthy. Here are some of the best food choices for XL Bullies.
- Protein: Chicken, beef, turkey, lamb
- Fat: Salmon oil, coconut oil
- Carbs: Sweet potatoes, oatmeal
- Fruits and vegetables: carrots, apples, blueberries
Top Food Selection for German Shepherds
German Shepherds are also food-motivated, but their diet is not as specialized as the XL Bully. They can usually get by on a standard dog food diet. However, some specific foods are still good for German Shepherds.
- Protein: Chicken, beef, turkey
- Fat: Salmon oil, coconut oil
- Carbs: Sweet potatoes, oatmeal
- Fruits and vegetables: carrots, apples, blueberries
Note that a dog’s diet widely affects its smooth coat, mental stimulation, and future health problems such as hip dysplasia and joint problems. Some health issues may not be avoidable, but a good diet can help reduce the risk.
Temperament
These dog breeds have different temperaments, which may or may not be suitable for your lifestyle. The XL Bully is an amiable and outgoing dog breed. They are great with kids and other pets and make excellent guard dogs.
The German Shepherd, on the other hand, is a loyal and protective dog breed. They are great with families but may be too much for first-time owners. They are also not recommended for homes with small children or other pets. They are brilliant and trainable, but they need firm and consistent training.
Both dogs are companion dogs material with early socialization, proper training, and a lot of love.
Intelligence
Before owning a new dog, you should research how easy it is to train them. The XL Bully is an intelligent breed, but they can sometimes be stubborn. They require firm and consistent training and daily exercise, but they are very rewarding to train. This new dog breed excels in obedience and agility training.
The German Shepherd is a highly intelligent breed, ranking number two out of 138. They are straightforward to train, but they need a lot of mental stimulation to stay happy and healthy. These powerful dogs are not first-time owners.
Both highly intelligent breeds, the XL Bully and German Shepherd, are great family members with the right owner.
Lifespan
Another factor you may consider when choosing a new dog is its lifespan. American Bully breeds like American Bulldogs and Staffordshire Bull Terriers have around 12 years. The German Shepherd has a slightly longer lifespan of about 13 years.
What affects a dog’s lifespan?
These dogs’ longevity may be affected by several factors such as:
Dog Size
Most dogs with a longer lifespan are small to medium breeds. The German Shepherd is a large breed, which may account for their slightly shorter lifespan. While American bully breeds like American Bulldogs and Staffordshire Bull Terriers are medium breeds, their lifespan is shorter for dogs their size.
Litter size
The number of puppies in a litter also plays a role in lifespan. Smaller litters tend to have healthier puppies that live longer.
Gender
Gender plays a role in lifespan but is not as significant as other factors. Male dogs have a shorter lifespan than female dogs, but the difference is only about one year.
Lighter body dogs may also have a slightly longer lifespan.
Pedigree
Another factor that may affect a dog’s lifespan is its pedigree. Dogs with mixed ancestry tend to have a longer lifespan than purebred dogs. It is because they are less likely to inherit genetic diseases.
The German Shepherd is a purebred dog, while the American Bullies are mixed breeds. It may be one reason the German Shepherd has a slightly shorter lifespan.
Living Conditions
Cleanliness and nutrition are essential for all dogs but especially important for dogs with a shorter lifespan. These breeds need to be fed a high-quality diet and have regular vet check-ups to ensure they are healthy.
American Bullies and German Shepherds are both medium to large breeds that need a lot of exercises. They should have access to a yard or park where they can run and play.
Cold weather can be hard on these breeds, so they should have a warm place to sleep inside.
Diet
Chronic diarrhea is one of the leading health problems that can shorten a dog’s life. That is why a high-quality diet is so important for dogs with a shorter lifespan. American Bullies and German Shepherds need a diet that is high in protein and low in fat.
They also need a diet rich in vitamins and minerals to support their immune system. A high-quality diet will help these dogs live a long and healthy life.
Diseases and Infections
Most dog breeds may suffer from specific health problems, but some breeds are more prone to certain diseases than others. American Bullies and German Shepherds are both susceptible to hip and elbow dysplasia.
Common Diseases on American Bully Breeds
American bully breeds like the XL bully and Pocket bully may suffer from the following health problems:
- Hip dysplasia
- Elbow dysplasia
- Allergies
- Skin problems
- Heart problems
- Cancer
- Liver diseases
Common Diseases on German Shepherd Breeds
German Shepherds are also susceptible to the following health problems:
- Hip and Elbow Dysplasia
- Degenerative Myelopathy
- Gastric Dilatation Volvulus
- Exocrine Pancreatic Insufficiency
- Cataracts
Understanding these common health problems will help you choose the right dog for your new family members.
Cost of Ownership
The cost of ownership is another essential factor to consider when choosing a new dog. American Bullies and German Shepherds are both medium to large breeds, so that they will need a lot of food.
They will also need regular vet check-ups and vaccinations. American Bullies and German Shepherds are both active breeds so they will need plenty of exercise.
The cost of ownership for these breeds is similar, but the German Shepherd may be slightly more expensive. It is because German Shepherds are purebred dogs, and their pedigree can affect the price.
Bully Breed Pricing
- Standard American Bully – ranges from $500 to $2500
- Xl American Bully – ranges from $1000 to $3500
- Pocket American Bully – ranges from $1200 to $4500
German Shepherd Pricing
- Puppies – range from $500 to $2000
- Adults – ranges from $1000 to $3500
The price of the dog is not the only cost you will incur. You will also need to factor in food, supplies, vet bills, and training costs.
Purchasing
When you are ready to purchase your American Bully or German Shepherd, there are a few things you need to keep in mind. Here are a few tips to help you find the right dog for your family.
1. Do your research
These companion dogs’ lineage and health should be carefully considered before making your final purchase.
2. Consider Kennel Club registration
If you are choosing a German Shepherd, ensure the breeder is registered with the Kennel Club. It will ensure that your dog is a purebred German Shepherd.
Kennel Club registration is not required for American Bullies, though the United Kennel Club (UKC) does offer registration for these dogs.
3. Choose a breeder that offers health guarantees
A reputable breeder will offer a health guarantee for their puppies. It is an essential factor to consider when choosing a breeder.
A health guarantee will give you peace of mind that your new puppy is healthy and free from genetic defects.
FAQs
Q: What is the difference between an American Bully and a German Shepherd?
A: The main difference between these two breeds is their size. American Bullies are a medium to large breed, while German Shepherds are a large breed.
Q: Which breed is more expensive?
A: German Shepherds are purebred dogs, so their pedigree can affect their price. American Bullies are not purebred dogs, so their price is not affected by their pedigree.
Q: Which breed is more prone to health problems?
A: American Bullies and German Shepherds are susceptible to hip and elbow dysplasia. German Shepherds are also vulnerable to degenerative myelopathy and gastric dilatation-volvulus. American Bullies are also exposed to allergies and skin problems.
Final Thoughts
When choosing between these two breeds, it is essential to consider your lifestyle and needs. The German Shepherd is an excellent choice if you are looking for a large breed dog that is protective of your family.
If you are looking for a medium to large breed dog that is loving and loyal, the American Bully is a great choice. Both breeds make excellent companion dogs, so the final decision is up to you!
May this guide help you choose the best furry friend to join your family.